Rattling the Act-gsac-use nest over linked libraries

It wouldn't be a BIM blog post without inventing some obscure, never-to-be-used again abbreviation would it?  In this case, actGSACuse stands for 'active Graphisoft ArchiCAD users'.

I tweeted this image last Friday (from ArchiCAD 10, file:///C:/Program Files/Graphisoft/ArchiCAD 10/Help/Files/01_Configuration.2.24.html):


The tweet:

I love that #Revit families live in the RVT.Found this pic on ArchiCAD 10 help...confused? (teasing @shoegnome ) twitter.com/lukeyjohnson/s…
— Luke Johnson (@lukeyjohnson) December 7, 2012

Embedded version of the help file:



This sparked an animated discussion on Twitter that essentially boils down to this:
is it better to have all project components (ArchiCAD libraries, Revit families) living in the project, or is it better to have them residing in a central server location where they are regularly updated and reloaded?

Personally, I believe there are pros and cons to each method.  I think an important consideration is Control -- if the library is Linked (ArchiCAD), do have the control over the program to say "hey, don't overwrite this component, I like it the way it is."  Similarly, if the components are all residing in a single project file (Revit), it would be nice to have the ability to one-click reload all updated families from a central Family RFA storage location.  I recall requesting this feature under some NDA project, but as yet, Revit can not do this without an add-in getting involved.

Along the lines of this discussion, I have created a new topic at BIMdebates:
BIMdebates: A central, live and linked component Library is better than static components in residing in a Project file


Why was I looking at an ArchiCAD 10 help file, you may rightly ask?  I was trying to upgrade an ArchiCAD 7.0 file and then export to IFC2x3.  However, I couldn't open it directly in ArchiCAD 16, so I had to open it in ArchiCAD 10 first.  I then wanted to embed the libraries, but I think embedded libraries first came to ArchiCAD in version 14?  So I basically had to open in ArchiCAD 10, save, then open in ArchiCAD 16, then embed libraries.  Then play around with IFC2x3 settings to make things come to Revit ok.  I haven't even looked at trying to open / upgrade / convert Plotmaker PMK files yet...

---

These PMK files are circa-2002.  Upon trying to open them in ArchiCAD 16, I get:
"You can only open files created by PlotMaker 3.0 or later."

Tried same process in ArchiCAD 10 - same message.